Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Annie: Goodspeed Gets It Right

From left: Skyla Joy Ward, Sadie Jean Williams, Anjali Roa, Laiken Jules, Ava Jay Fernandez, Issa Gonzalez, and Adilyn Bickley in Annie. (Photo: Diane Sobolewski.)

At this point I’ve seen five versions of Annie, including the 1982 John Huston movie and the two television adaptations. The current revival at the Goodspeed Opera House (playing through January 2) is the first one I’ve liked. (I didn’t see the original 1977 Broadway production.) The last one, a hit for the Stratford Shakespeare Festival during their 2025 season, was so wound up that I was worn down by intermission. By contrast, Jenn Thompson, who has staged it for Goodspeed, achieves a relaxed finesse. The musical, culled from Harold Gray’s comic strip Little Orphan Annie, is a modest family entertainment, which in these Disneyfied days feels like a small gift. The book by Thomas Meehan is pleasant and uncomplicated, though the New York City Depression-era accoutrements lend it color and tension and link it to early-thirties movie musicals like Hallelujah, I’m a Bum! and Gold Diggers of 1933. The Charles Strouse-Martin Charnin songs aren’t top-drawer except for the irresistible orphans’ lament “It’s the Hard Knock Life”; if you want to hear Strouse at his best, check out his work on Golden Boy (lyrics by Lee Adams) and Rags (Stephen Schwartz); the tunes he and Adams came up with for their breakthrough show Bye Bye Birdie have more wit and invention. But the score to Annie is enjoyable enough, and under Adam Souza’s music direction the ensemble performs it exuberantly.

In this mounting that juvenile belter Annie is played by Laiken Jules and her sextet of pals, trapped in an orphanage that’s more like a workhouse under the iron fist of the dipsomaniacal Miss Hannigan (Emily Skinner), are Anjali Roa, Sadie Jean Williams, Skyla Joy Ward, Adalyn Bickley, Issa Gonzalez and Ava J. Fernandez. “It’s the Hard Knock Life” is the second song (after Annie’s wistful “Maybe”) and the seven little girls render it splendidly. All of them can dance as well as sing, and the choreographer, Patricia Wilcox, has dreamed up a raucous, playful set of moves that brings out their best.

Annie manages to get away from the orphanage when Grace Farrell, personal assistant to the billionaire Oliver Warbucks, drops by the orphanage to find an orphan to spend the Christmas holidays in his mansion. She’s so taken with Annie that she ignores the harridan Hannigan’s efforts to persuade her to land on some other candidate. Naturally Warbucks is enchanted with Annie and decides to adopt her. But she has been keeping her hope alive that the parents who left her as a baby eleven years ago are bound to come back for her someday – and hanging on to the broken locket that is her only memento of them. So Warbucks stages a hunt for them with a $5000 reward at the end. Hannigan’s disreputable brother Rooster and Rooster’s inamorata Lily, working in tandem with her, decide to impersonate the missing parents and collect the prize. The plot is merely passable but the period details are very appealing – and Alejo Vietti’s costume designs do a fine job of picking them up. And the book contains some snappy jokes, like the way the resilient orphan girls win almost every round against the frequently inebriated Hannigan and the idea that Annie’s unassailable optimism inspires FDR to dream up the New Deal. (The musical takes place during his first year in the White House.)

The adults in the cast provide the backbone of the show. Christopher Swan lines his gruffness with enough warmth to make Annie’s effortlessly charming Warbucks perfectly plausible, even though Meehan should have written a book scene to dramatize the change in his character. Julia Nicole Hunter brings elegance and a more understated charm to the role of Grace. Rhett Guyer and Devin Holloway handle the dance solos deftly as Rooster and the radio crooner/tapper Bert Healy. (The radio broadcast sequence isn’t one of the high points of this version, but Holloway rescues it.) Mark Woodard has a lot of fun with a light impersonation of Roosevelt. The one disappointment is Kelly Berman, who can sing and dance but fails to make much of an impression as Rooster’s equally ruthless paramour Lily.

Emily Skinner as Miss Hannigan. (Photo: Diane Sobolewski.)

I’ve always liked watching Emily Skinner, about half of whose Broadway performances I’ve seen, but generally I feel let down because they don’t do enough with her. (That’s certainly what I thought when I saw New York, New York.) Skinner was the main reason I wanted to see this Annie, and she gives an old-pro reading of the part. She also looks beautiful in Vietti’s thirties clothes, which hang on her tall frame so splendidly that this Hannigan manages to maintain a core of glamor that years of lonely tippling haven’t soured. (I love what Ashley Rae Callahan has done with her hair, piling it beehive-high.) Skinner isn’t ideal for this part: she’s not a clown like Dorothy Loudon, who played it during the original Broadway run, or Carol Burnett, whose triumphant rendition in the misbegotten Huston movie makes it worth watching. What Skinner contributes instead is a hard-boiled approach with a realist core.

Finally I’d like to credit the chorus, who play Hooverville residents, Manhattan newcomers, domestics in the Warbucks mansion and members of FDR’s cabinet. Anyone who has been attending Goodspeed musicals regularly over the years knows that the singer-dancers who cycle in and out of them are wonderfully talented. Annie is a boon for these performers: it contains half a dozen ensemble numbers. Every one shows them off.

– Steve Vineberg is Distinguished Professor of the Arts and Humanities at College of the Holy Cross in Worcester, Massachusetts, where he teaches theatre and film. He also writes for The Threepenny Review and is the author of three books: Method Actors: Three Generations of an American Acting Style; No Surprises, Please: Movies in the Reagan Decade; and High Comedy in American Movies.

No comments:

Post a Comment